Sophie York, Barrister, Law Lecturer and Director of the Royal Automobile Club of Australia.
To the attendees at the ACM Conference at RACA on Friday 13th Nov 2026
Dear Friends,
I would have cherished being with you today; please accept my sincere apologies —I am heading to an interstate wedding!
Today you are in the esteemed company of two extraordinary Australians, and may I offer some hearty words in support of them both.
Please note, these are my personal views and not those of any organisation.
Ladies First!
Senator Pauline Hanson
I have had the pleasure of meeting Pauline in person, serendipitously, on a couple of occasions. She struck me as warm and genuine.
I consider her to be one of the bravest figures in our Parliament.
For almost thirty years, I (and many other Australians) have had the opportunity to observe her on the public stage, give or take a few gaps where she was not actually serving in our nation’s illustrious elected parliament. At one stage, as we all know, she was serving time in rather more spartan accommodation! 😊
From the outset of Pauline’s public life, I noticed how ridiculed this lady was, for things which were nothing to do with her policies, nor her character. So, for example, derogatory comments were all about her red hair, her no-nonsense demeanour and her voice with its particular Aussie accent! She was even nicknamed “The Oxley Moron” when running for the seat of Oxley.
Her public life actually commenced earlier, when she ran for and won elected office in 1994, as a local councillor. She then ran as a Liberal candidate in the seat of Oxley, which was a safe Labor seat. She was disendorsed so late in the campaign that she still appeared on the ballot paper as a Liberal. She won the seat and entered Federal Parliament as an Independent.
The disendorsement by the Liberal Party was allegedly for a (perhaps) inelegantly expressed concern about governmental favouritism and funding for Indigenous people, in a letter to The Queensland Times published on 6th January 1996. She acknowledged that there had been wrong treatment of Aboriginal people in the past. She may not have read philosopher John Rawls’ ‘Theory of Justice’, where he postulates that it is “just and fair” to give the worst-off in a society a helping hand up! Nonetheless, Pauline was noting that the qualifying criteria for the government largesse was “any” minuscule percentage of indigeneity. She was in fact making a number of accurate observations: being indigenous itself does not of itself necessarily mean being the worst-off in Australian society; that ill-directed taxpayer-funded windfalls may hamper self-initiated advancement; and that excessive and poorly-targeted favouritism itself breeds resentment and division. In short, and to paraphrase: “need” rather than “race” ought to be the guide for governmental assistance.
The noted philosopher Wittgenstein observed that the limits of language can limit one’s world. What seems to have happened with Pauline is that whilst she was in her early years of public life, she expressed her concerns bluntly. Instead of the commentariat seeking to understand her points, she was punished for not expressing them in the sophisticated words of an academic. And yet most Australians are not academics by profession. She had been working in a small family business that sold fish and chips. Why was there such snobbery about how she expressed herself?
Some of Pauline’s concerns expressed in that letter of 1996 – about government actions creating a racial divide – were vindicated much later by the national referendum in October 2023 on The Voice. Australians expressed clearly that they do not want a country divided by race. And prominent Indigenous speakers, such as Warren Mundine and Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, agreed.
On the topic of inelegant speech, in more recent times Pauline has become enmeshed in a court case where a Greens Senator, Mehreen Faruqi, tweeted something highly disrespectful about the Queen and British history just after Her Majesty, a long-serving dignified monarch for 70 years, much-loved and respected by countless people across the world, had passed away. The timing and context of Faruqi’s tweet were grotesquely inappropriate, let alone being content of opportunistic partisan political content. It seemed a very un-Australian tweet, given that most Australians would think dancing on a woman’s grave so promptly and publicly is a pretty gross thing to do, irrespective of politics.
It is fascinating from a jurisprudential perspective that under current law you can deride an Australian fair-skinned Celtic woman’s British heritage with impunity, yet it seems (so far) that Pauline, in essence, is forbidden to express her own stout opinions in return.
We must respect the justice system. The enduring statue of Lady Justice carries scales and a sword — and wears the blindfold of impartiality. We will all know soon enough if the High Court is the arbiter of “manners” required henceforth in political debate in Australia. And also whether our Constitution affords protection for robust political banter.
Respect is a two-way street. Societally, most Australians tend to give people a fair go, no matter where they are from. In any society, there are elements of friction, particularly if division is stoked by political favouritism. On key metrics – such as what Australians legislate, make policies about and fund – as well as equal standing before the justice system – we are the least racist country on earth.
In an article in 2003, the Age newspaper sagely reported on: “The rise and fall of Pauline Hanson”. Even Mark Twain would laugh – reports of her political demise were so premature and exaggerated!
Pauline bounced back, and our country is the better for it.
Why? Because her bravery and forthrightness enable us all to speak more freely about what concerns us. A free country depends upon free speech. If we cannot share ideas, we are no longer fully human. Many great discoveries in science and realisations in philosophy were originally discomfiting. When Pauline wore a burka into the Australian Parliament, yes, it was confronting. It was stark, blunt, and it was visual. An image that spoke a thousand words. It led to important discussions about where we are headed culturally as a nation – do we want a country where women are told what to wear? And be punished for breaching? Because that is the reality for women in at least 14 countries of the world. And female education is restricted in these countries also. Many other freedoms are restricted also, such as freedom of speech and religion. People are migrating to Australia, in ever-increasing numbers, from those countries. Some newcomers support these restrictive views; others do not. This topic might be merely a theoretical topic for this generation of Australians, but it might not be as theoretical for the next few generations.
In other matters, we are all concerned about the environment – of course we all want fresh air, flourishing forests and beautiful seascapes! What Australians don’t want are our institutions corrupted. And they don’t want laws and policies based upon suspect evidence. When global-warming theories are pursued which are either not evidence-based or the evidence has been manipulated, and when enormous taxpayer money follows this corrupted data, Australians become rightly concerned.
So when, for example, it’s been reported that the Bureau of Meteorology has disturbing reliability issues regarding the accuracy of its long-term temperature records, we want this looked into, we want it all corrected, and we want consequences if there has been tampering! And when it comes to the crucial issue of water, and our farmers are beside themselves, Pauline proposes a Royal Commission into the Murray-Darling Basin; of course, people pay attention!
The archaeologist William Boyd Dawkins presented a groundbreaking scientific paper in 1862 that mentioned three stages before acceptance.
Three inevitable objections which all new and startling facts in science will encounter.
First, “that it is not true”.
Secondly, “that it is contrary to religion [or prevailing orthodoxy],”
Third, the stage in which people say “Everyone knew it before.”
When it comes to Pauline and her home-grown wisdom, as her cut-through on simply wanting what is best for Australia catches on…we will start hearing that “everyone knew it before”.
And at that point, her viewpoints will become truly accepted.
Pauline may not ever get the credit.
People in high places will claim “everyone knew it before”.
Nobody is perfect, but the reality is that Pauline is speaking up, boldly and determinedly, for many everyday Australians.
Some will never admire her.
But for that alone – for valiantly speaking up, giving it to us straight, in a febrile world – she deserves our respect.
Thank you — and enjoy a thought-provoking conference!
Best wishes,
Sophie York
